Related
Summary
It ’s often take that Severus Snape would have committed several murders before killing Albus Dumbledore , but some arguments could be made that this instance inHarry Potterwas his first metre . Avada Kedavra seemed to be a stock go for the Death Eaters during the two Wizarding Wars . Voldemort especially had no qualms with using the curse word around every nook . As a member of the Dark Lord ’s inner circle , Snape might have been expected to torture and kill Muggles and wizard - kind alike , but since theHarry Potterbooks and movies provide no concrete examples , this could be debated .
InHarry Potter and the Half - Blood Prince , Dumbledore planned his own dying with Snape so that Draco Malfoy could be spared the burden of put murder . Of course , even Dumbledore ’s closest confidants did n’t recognize about this arrangement , so it seemed to both the Order of the Phoenix and Voldemort ’s Death Eaters that Snape had vote out the headmaster in stale blood . It was n’t until the end ofHarry Potter and the Deathly HallowsthatHarry learned that his Potions Master had been a double agent , solidly on Dumbledore ’s side since Lily Potter ’s death . Still , Snape had once been a echt Death Eater .
The timeline of Severus Snape ’s life is full of tragedy , and though he was never fully good or big , his history provide the foundation of Harry Potter .
It’s Assumed That Snape Killed As A Death Eater (But It’s Never Specifically Mentioned)
Though it ’s not clear precisely when Snape became a Death Eater , it must have been presently after leaving Hogwarts since he was only 21 years sometime when Voldemort slay Lily and James Potter . to boot , inSnape ’s memories inDeathly Hallows , Lily accused Snape of aspiring to become one of Voldemort ’s follower when he left school — something he could n’t deny . If he achieved this goal as quick after turning 17 as he hope , it ’s hard to suppose that Snape managed four yr as a Death Eater without killing anyone .
Voldemort ’s growing power roll around wizarding supremacy , and it ’s known that , during the First Wizarding War , the Dark Lord and his following attack and killed infinite Muggles and Muggle - born witch and wizards . This was the main appealingness of Voldemort ’s mission for Snape since his abusive father had been a Muggle . It ’s also crucial to remember that notallVoldemort ’s followers were Death Eaters — this title was reserved for those in the Dark Lord ’s internal circle . If Snape had made it to such a rank , Voldemort would likely have required proof of loyalty , and nothing would have address louder than blood .
There ’s a common hypothesis that Snape earned Voldemort ’s confidence and the status of Death Eater by polish off his Muggle father . This would explain why Voldemort stated that he and Snape had so much in common .
There Are Hints In The Harry Potter Books That Snape Never Directly Killed Anyone
There are some valid arguments that support the call that Dumbledore was Snape ’s first lineal putting to death . ThoughtheHarry Pottermoviesmissed this fact , the books put a lot of focus on the consequence of murder on a person ’s soul . Regardless of whether someone is wee a Horcrux , killing splits the soul into piece , and the only way to repair the damage is for the person who committed the crime to feel genuine remorse . It ’s presuppose to be a horribly painful mental process , and one that Voldemort and many of his followers were unequal to of . Dumbledore mentioned in Snape ’s memories that this was why he did n’t require Draco to be the one to kill him , to which Snape reply , " And my individual , Dumbledore ? "
The fact that Snape was concerned for his individual betoken that it had not yet been damage in such a manner . Still , if his soul had already been furbish up by remorse , he may have been concerned about rive his soulagain — but the behavior of other Death Eaters toward Snape suggests otherwise . Bellatrix Lestrange was never win over that Snape was on Voldemort ’s side , accusing the man of doing nothing of value to Voldemort ’s cause . She seemed to believe that his skills did n’t extend beyond being a undercover agent , which imply that he was n’t one of Voldemort ’s fightersbut had a more passive part instead .
irrespective of whether Snape became a spy for Dumbledore , Crouch would n’t have allow the adult male to take the air free if there was any proof of murder .
ultimately , and perhaps the most convincing argument , is that despite Snape being a known Death Eater , Dumbledore ’s password was enough to keep him out of Azkaban following the First Wizarding War . Igor Karkaroff gave Barty Crouch Sr specific details regarding the crimes of his fellow Death Eaters , and the Ministry functionary cast even his own boy in prison house as a result . However , when Karakaroff named Snape , he acknowledge nothing of the humanity ’s existent crime apart from being a Death Eater . no matter of whether Snape became a undercover agent for Dumbledore , Crouch would n’t have take into account the homo to take the air free if there was any proof of murder .
Barty Crouch Jr and his father were involved in the central mystery of Goblet of Fire , but the Harry Potter movies left out their dark secret .
Snape Indirectly Killed Lily & James In Harry Potter (& Felt Excruciating Remorse)
Of of course , just because Snape might not have directly murdered anyone , this is n’t to say that he was blameless . The new Death Eater had been the one to pass on Professor Trelawney ’s prognostication to Voldemort , and this is what take the Dark Lord to the Potters . Snape in secret switch to Dumbledore ’s side in hope that Lily would be protected , but it was no good . The damage had been done , and it was all Snape ’s fault that Lily and James Potter were killed . As a spy , the Potters would n’t have been the only single killed because of Snape . Even if he had never directly mutilate , he had blood on his hands , andHarry Potterimplies that this involve his somebody all the same .
When Snape and Dumbledore metfollowing Lily ’s death , the untried Death Eater was clearly devastated . Dumbledore have it off Snape had desired Lily , but he was surprised by the level at which he mourned . He said , " Is this remorse , Severus ? " to which Snape answer that he wished he were dead . The use of the intelligence " remorse " here is meaning since it had already been established inHarry Potterthat compunction was the only direction to heal the soul after slaying . The pain Snape have here was the price for all he had done , and the self-reproach led to the conclusion to protect Lily ’s son . Snape was far from blameless , and he committed murder in one form or another . Still , through his previous human activity inHarry Potter , it ’s clean-cut that he choke with a united — if not marred — psyche .
Harry Potter is a multimedia system dealership about an orphaned son who enrolls at Hogwarts School of Wizardry , where he see the truth about himself , his family , and the terrible evil that obsess the magical world . conform from the novels , Harry Potter is an eight - sequence film saga that follows the journey of Harry Potter and his friends , Hermoine Granger and Ron Weasley , as they navigate the tricky existence of growing up , schooltime life , and magic . Starting from class one and travel to their seventh class , the films chronicle the student ' time at Hogwarts while unroll a baleful plot that centers around the unsuspecting Harry . With the takings of the dark wizard , Voldemort , the student and professors at Hogwarts will fight to channel on as the world around them may exchange forever . Harry Potter has extend beyond the world of its motion picture and novels with several picture biz , a spin - off film series style Fantastic wildcat , and even draw at Universal Studios .
Harry Potter is a multimedia franchise about an orphaned boy who enrolls at Hogwarts School of Wizardry, where he learns the truth about himself, his family, and the terrible evil that haunts the magical world. Adapted from the novels, Harry Potter is an eight-episode film saga that follows the journey of Harry Potter and his friends, Hermoine Granger and Ron Weasley, as they navigate the tricky world of growing up, school life, and magic. Starting from year one and moving to their seventh year, the films chronicle the students' time at Hogwarts while unfurling a sinister plot that centers around the unsuspecting Harry. With the return of the dark wizard, Voldemort, the students and professors at Hogwarts will fight to carry on as the world around them may change forever. Harry Potter has expanded beyond the world of its films and novels with several video games, a spin-off film series titled Fantastic Beasts, and even attractions at Universal Studios.
