Related
Summary
TheHarry Potterbooks and films are incredibly detailed , yet they leave behind certain question unrequited , and onetragic buff theory justifies Aunt Petunia ’s choler and gall far better than the script . Harry Potter lose his parents , Lily and James , when he was just a baby , and the audience watched him deal with an unloving family home before head to Hogwarts . His aliveness with the Dursleys was miserable , and it was never amply decipherable why Aunt Petunia was that bitter toward him .
Throughout theHarry Potterfranchise , Aunt Petunia and Uncle Vernon gave Harry shelter , first during his puerility , and by and by when he returned from Hogwarts during summer breaks . The Dursleys were not nice citizenry , and they were always mean to Harry , despite lavishing their son , Dudley with honey , gifts , and aid . The Dursleys hate deception because they were very normal people who cared about what other people suppose and hated drawing attention to themselves , yetAunt Petunia hated her sister Lilyso deeply , and a new theory might justify why .
The Golden Trio engage half a Harry Potter book to figure out how to get rid of a Horcrux , but a solution may have been nearer than they thought .
A Tragic Harry Potter Theory Blames Death Eaters For Killing Lily & Petunia’s Parents
Their parents' deaths weren’t addressed in the films or books
A hypothesis suggests that the reasonableness why Aunt Petunia hates Lily so much is because Death Eaters kill Lily and Petunia ’s parents . Aunt Petunia was Harry ’s only living congeneric , and what happened to Harry Potter ’s grandparent was not address in the book or film . Aunt Petunia treated Harry horribly during his childhood , but blaming the Wizarding World for defeat her parent cause sense . Thesad Harry Potter theorygoes on to exact that theDeath Eaters killed their parents while they were searching for Lily and James ' private location , before finding them in Godric ’s Hollow thanks to Petter Pettigrew .
Voldemort was a powerful wizard with a huge following , so it would n’t have been impossible for him to find Lily ’s parents . He could ’ve post the Death Eaters to torture Lily ’s parents for information , killing them after they failed to fork over the expected solvent . That manner , it would make sense for Petunia to hate magic so deeply , and still begrudge her sis , because she would ’ve blame Lily for their parent ' end at the hands of the Death Eaters .
This Theory Makes More Sense Than Aunt Petunia’s Motives In The Books
It would justify her hatred of magic more
InHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows , it was revealed that Petunia was jealous because she never got her letter . She even write a alphabetic character to Professor Albus Dumbledore , postulate him to hang Hogwarts . However , this theory make more horse sense than Aunt Petunia ’s motivation in the book and films . It would n’t make mother wit to still be that angry after all those years just because she could n’t be a witch and Lily could . Even if that had been the original reason for her hatred , her sister ’s passing should ’ve erased all of that , particularly as Aunt Petunia was happily married to Vernon Dursley and had Dudley , and the aliveness she always wanted .
This possibility would free Petunia ’s passionate hatred towards Lily , Harry , and magic trick , even so many twelvemonth later . She would ’ve eventually moved on from not becoming a witch , peculiarly after bring in it was mostly dangerous given Lily ’s death . However , her choler after all these class would make more sentiency if she blamed a tragedy like the Death Eaters kill her parents on the Wizarding World , and , subsequently , her sister .
Harry Potter Canon Debunks This Theory
J.K. Rowling had a different explanation
Although this tragic theory makes sense and would justify Aunt Petunia ’s bass hate for trick and her baby , it ’s not what happened . J.K. Rowling later excuse whathappened to Harry Potter ’s grandparents , and clarified that Lily and Petunia ’s parents died of a " normal , Muggle last . " Their parents were Muggles and had no tie with the Wizarding World until Lily get her afterward . Aunt Petunia reveals inHarry Potter and the Sorcerer ’s Stonetheir parent were still alert when Lily go away to Hogwarts , adding that they were " proud " of her . So , their deaths pass off either while Lily was attending Hogwarts , or in the short time after her graduation .
Despite Lily and Petunia ’s parent being presumably vernal when they died , there were many ways they could ’ve had " a normal Muggle death . " It could ’ve been an chance event or a disease , as Rowling did n’t add more entropy about when or how they died . Although Petunia never spoke of Lily , her hate of her could have been because she was virulent that she could n’t have been a part of it , and she hated magic even more after Lily ’s death . Even so , theHarry Pottertheory of Death Eaters killing their parents return a estimable account than the books , and it would ’ve offered Petunia a strong reason to hate the Wizarding World .
