Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
Summary
Major Kira ( Nana Visitor ) achieved something inStar Trek : Deep Space NinethatStar Trek : Voyager ’s Commander Chakotay ( Robert Beltran ) would never have attempted . As number one to Captains Benjamin Sisko ( Avery Brooks ) and Kathryn Janeway ( Kate Mulgrew ) severally , Kira and Chakotay had quite similar backgrounds . In theDS9pilot , Commander Sisko specifically requests a non - Starfleet ship’s officer as his number one , to offer penetration into Bajoran interests . In theVoyagerpilot , Chakotay is also specifically chosen as Janeway ’s deputy due to the unique circumstances of suffer a spaceship crewed by Starfleet officers and Maquis freedom belligerent .
Sadly , Star Trek : Voyagerlargely ignored the striking potential of hold two ideologically opposed crews form together to survive in the unmapped Delta Quadrant . WhereStar Trek : Deep Space Ninequestioned Gene Rodenberry ’s utopian vision of the futurity to create compelling character drama , Voyagerlargely stuck to the " no interpersonal conflict " rule imposed uponStar Trek : The Next Generation . This stand for that , despite some notable exceptions , the engagement between the Maquis , Chakotay and Janewaywas non - existent . However , the same could n’t be said forDS9 ’s Kira and Sisko .
Star Trek : Voyager resoundingly failed Chakotay as a character , but despite his account issues , Prodigy has a probability to turn Chakotay around .
DS9’s Kira Did What Chakotay Would Never Do On Voyager
InStar Trek : Deep Space Nineseason 1 , episode 18 , " Dramatis Personae " , Major Kira stages a mutiny after Sisko allows a Valerian ship to tail at the station . Kira believes that the Valerians are still supplying the Cardassian Union with cloth to build weapon , but Sisko points out that she lacks sufficient grounds . Kira and Sisko regularly clashed over such matter inDS9 ’s early days , and the influence of a telepathic archive is enough to tip those tensions into a full - blown mutiny . While Kira is work out a diachronic great power conflict rather than present a existent mutiny , she still take more action mechanism than Chakotay did duringStar Trek : Voyager .
A force struggle between the Maquis and Starfleet crowd felt like the most obvious story forStar Trek : Voyagerto enjoin , but it never materialized . WhenVoyagervillain Seska(Martha Hackett ) , one of the Maquis crew members , rick on the crowd of the USS Voyager , it was because she was an hole-and-corner Cardassian operative . It was n’t untilVoyagerseason 3 that a Maquis mutiny took place aboard the ship , albeit in an incendiary holodeck simulation create by Lt . Tuvok ( Tim Russ ) . Tuvok would by and by run a Maquis mutiny in the final time of year , when he was activated by a dormant telepathic signal . Of all the mutiny and might struggles aboard the USS Voyager , Chakotay was never at the nub of them .
Chakotay Was Why Voyager’s Maquis Never Mutinied
It was only in theStar Trek : Voyagerseason 5 finale , " Equinox " , that Chakotay ever came close to staging a mutiny . Janeway ’s obsession with bringing Captain Rudolph Ransom ( John Savage ) and the crew of the USS Equinox to justice put the crew at risk and storm Chakotay to consider cross that line . finally , he decided that a mutiny was n’t in the upright interests of the Voyager crew . Despite their shared story of resisting Cardassian occupation , a willingness to mutiny is the major dispute betweenVoyager ’s Chakotay andStar Trek : Deep Space Nine ’s Major Kira .
All episodes ofStar Trek : Deep Space NineandStar Trek : Voyagerare useable to stream on Paramount+ .
