Related
Summary
Marvel Studios’Scarlet WitchandJean Greymay battle in the futurity of theMCU , and as two of the most potent characters in the Marvel Universe , their competitiveness would certainly be a sight to lay eyes on . TheScarlet Witch and Jean Greyhave never had the chance to meet in live - action , as Elizabeth Olsen ’s Wanda Maximoff has inhabited the MCU , while Famke Janssen and Sophie Turner ’s interpretation of Jean Grey were confine to Fox ’s X - Men Universe . However , Disney ’s 2019 acquisition of twentieth Century Fox made their meeting in the MCU much more likely , so both may have the chance to show off their unbelievable ability , incomparable to other MCU fighter .
Jean Grey was the first of this span to come out in Marvel Comics , debut in 1963’sThe X - homo # 1 , while Wanda Maximoff joined afterwards in 1964’sThe X - Men # 4 . For several decades , both were depicted as mutant , but theScarlet Witch ’s backstorywas retconned in 2015 , making her ability the direct result of experimentation by the High Evolutionary , rather , though she was also born as a witch with innate magnate . The Scarlet Witch and Jean Grey have very dissimilar origins in Marvel Comics , and in their live - action iteration , but their power are actually unusually similar , induce them two of the most formidable and notable female hero sandwich in the Marvel Universe .
The ten - Men franchise has already failed twice to tell the story Marvel Studios has told quite well with Wanda Maximoff aka The Scarlet Witch .
Scarlet Witch’s Chaos Magic Vs. Jean Grey’s Mutation
In the MCU , Elizabeth Olsen ’s Wanda Maximoffwas introduced with a range of powerful ability connected to her harnessing of " topsy-turvydom magic " . While Wanda was born as a crone with some innate abilities , these powers were enhanced after she was disclose to the Mind Stone while subject herself to HYDRA experimentation . The Scarlet Witch ’s chaos magic gifts her powers including telekinesis , psychical energy manipulation , levitation , force - field of force projection and telepathy , which earmark her to manipulate the minds of other somebody . She has also expose a mastery of typical witchcraft , including spellcasting , teleportation and transmutation , though her most telling gift is that of altering realness itself .
Portrayed by both Famke Janssen and Sophie Turner , Jean Grey in Fox ’s tenner - Men Universedemonstrated alike abilities to the Scarlet Witch . Jean Grey was hold a mutant , and her powers emerge as a child , inadvertently causing her family elevator car to collapse . Jean ’s master ability is telekinesis , allowing her to move object with her mind , but she also uses this to fly , firing vigour blasts and manipulate objects on a molecular horizontal surface . Jean Grey is also capable of telepathy , magic trick projection , foreknowledge and memory manipulation , and is regarded as the only Class 5 sport in Fox ’s X - Men Universe , make her extremely potent even before she bonded with the cosmic Phoenix Force .
Scarlet Witch Has Better Control Over Her Abilities
While both Wanda Maximoff and Jean Grey have a huge amount of great power , the MCU ’s Scarlet Witch has a much better handle and apprehension of her giving than Jean Grey in Fox ’s ten - Men Universe . Of course , it has taken several years for Wanda to fully sympathise her rightful potential drop , and interview have watched her abilities and self-assurance grow exponentially since her 2014 debut . Her powers take a huge bounce forward duringAvengers : Infinity War , where Wanda displayed the strength to demolish an Infinity Stone , andPhase 4’sWandaVisionandDoctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madnesssaw her finally embrace her full power , though not for completely heroic gains .
Jean Grey ’s situation is a little less square - forward , as her index were limited from a young age thanks to mental closure put in spot by Charles Xavier , a.k.a . Professor X.Jean Grey is perhaps the most powerful mutantin Fox ’s X - Men Universe , but never get the chance to show off the full extent of her power , as Xavier had dulled - down her gifts to protect herself and those around her . This means thatJean Grey has footling discernment of what she ’s in reality capable of , and has never had the luck to full embrace these ability , so the Scarlet Witch would be much more adaptable in a high - pressing fight billet between them .
Jean Grey Has Been Trained By Professor X
Even though the Scarlet Witch may have a clearer understanding of the extent of her power , Wanda Maximoff has never get any formal preparation in the MCU , and has only been capable to organically perfect her abilities over several years . This entail that Wanda is often sloppy when using her gifts , and sometimes take a crap major mistakes that could even cost lives , such as her activity inLagos during 2016’sCaptain America : Civil War . With nobody else in the MCU who harbors gift similar to her , it ’s surely difficult to envisage anyone train Wanda in how to use her talent , but this is where Fox ’s Jean Grey has the upper hand .
In Fox ’s X - Men Universe , everymember of the disco biscuit - Men teamhas received direct training from Professor X in how to harness and hone their unique abilities , including Jean Grey . Despite the limitations in her mind , Jean Grey is still able to beg into a huge amount of power , and she is able to operate these abilities because of aid devote to her from Xavier . Jean ’s work with the decade - Men in both timelines has give her the chance to put this to the tryout , and continued training mean that she is always learning from her mistakes and working out how to do better , which is very unlike to the Scarlet Witch .
Scarlet Witch Is Capable Of Altering Reality
Marvel Studios ' Phase 4 eventually demonstrated theScarlet Witch ’s most impressive power , as 2021’sWandaVisionsaw Wanda Maximoff spay realism itself . DuringWandaVision , Wanda ’s corporate grief over losing her parent , her buddy and Vision culminate in her create her own world in the town of Westview , New Jersey . Inside the Westview Hex , the rules of cathartic bent to Wanda ’s own design . She was able-bodied to transmute every aspect of her world to fit the differing meter periods of her situation comedy - elan humanity , she manipulated the minds of every Westview resident to wedge them to limn character inside the Hex , and she was capable to expand the Hex at will .
This was , by far , the most expansive demonstration of the Scarlet Witch ’s chaos magic power , as she was even able to create a variant of her lost love , Vision , and produce two minor , Billy and Tommy Maximoff , who also extract superpowers . This go on before Wanda descend into will power of the Darkhold , which allow her to traverse alternating realities in the MCU ’s multiverse , expanding her kitchen stove of abilities further . This kind of realness warp is something that Fox ’s Jean Grey was never capable of pulling off , perhaps suggest that the Scarlet Witch could simply alter the creation at its most canonical level to entrap Jean Greyin her own makeshift world .
The Darkhold is the MCU ’s Book of the Damned . It ’s continued utilization corrupts its proofreader , thrust them to take utmost and dark actions to complete their commission . The Darkhold has been read to sully the Scarlet Witch and several variants of Doctor Strange in the MCU .
The Phoenix Force Enhances Jean Grey Massively
While Jean Grey never showed off natural reality warping ability in Fox ’s X - Men Universe , her bond with the Phoenix Force enhanced her mutant powers beyond belief . In Fox ’s originalX - Mentimeline , Famke Janssen’sJean Grey became the Dark Phoenix inX - Men : The Last Stand . During the 2006 project , Jean Grey ’s telekinetic and telepathic powers were dramatically increase , making her open of decompose Professor X with slight effort and play with the rules of gravity . However , The Last Standrelegated the adaptation of Marvel Comics’Dark Phoenix Sagato a side - plot of ground , but 2019’sX - Men : Dark Phoenixput this storyline front - and - center .
hug drug - Men : Dark Phoenixarguably adaptedThe Dark Phoenix Sagamuch more faithfully , as , despite its flaws , Sophie Turner ’s Jean Grey tie with the cosmic Phoenix Force rather than turning to the dark side without otherworldly intercession . The Phoenix Force immensely amplify Jean ’s mutant abilities , allowing her to overpower the likes ofProfessor X and Magneto , as well as take down the extraterrestrial D’Bari without hesitation . The Phoenix Force give her the power to control cosmic forces , adapt to extreme environments and revitalize herself after injury . Both these adaptations have failed to show Jean Grey ’s Phoenix power to their full voltage , but Marvel Studios could change this .
Scarlet Witch Vs. Jean Grey: Who Would Win?
Even though it might be quite some time beforeMarvel Studios exact onThe Dark Phoenix Saga , there have been call for a true adaptation of the Marvel Comics storyline to be adapted in the ever - amplify MCU.X - humanity : The Last StandandX - Men : Dark Phoenixboth run out to show the full extent of Jean Grey ’s Phoenix magnate , but her first appearance and appropriate set - up in the MCU could at last deliver what watcher have been hoping for . endow by the Phoenix Force in the MCU , Jean Grey ’s mutant powers would perhaps equal the chaos magic abilities of the Scarlet Witch , make a struggle between the two an epic cinematic spectacle .
Jean Grey is an Omega level mutant , think of there is simply no limit to what she can accomplish .
Without the Phoenix Force , it ’s likely that Wanda Maximoff would be able to best Jean Grey in battle , as she has tycoon far outweighing the ten - Men phallus , especially with Professor X ’s limitations in Jean Grey ’s nous . However , if the Scarlet Witch and Jean Grey engage in battle with both at full power , it ’s more possible to imagine the latter stimulate the upper deal . With the Phoenix Force , Jean Grey is an Z level mutant , meaning there is just no limit to what she can carry through , andthough the Scarlet Witch would certainly put up a strong , mind - bend fight , Jean Grey would likely take the triumph during this Brobdingnagian battle .
Will The Scarlet Witch & Jean Grey Ever Battle In The MCU?
After the events of 2022’sDoctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness , Elizabeth Olsen ’s Scarlet Witch is on the face of it drained in the MCU , realize her futurity in the franchise unclear , though there is speculation she will be returning . Conversely , Marvel Studios has begun development on itsX - Menreboot , signify it may not be too much longer before Jean Grey is introduced to the MCU . Should theScarlet Witchreturn in the MCU ’s future , it ’s entirely possible that her connection to mutants in Marvel Comics would represent a struggle between Olsen ’s witch and the MCU’sJean Grey , though it will surely be quite some time before this extremely - prognosticate engagement becomes a world .
