Related
Summary
In theOscars ' 94 - year account , only six actor have ever been nominate for playing the same character on disjoined affair . It ’s not rare for different portrayals of thesame quality to be propose or even advance an Oscar . However , in these instances , the character is played by dissimilar actor , typically in remaking of the original movie .
Many thespian do reprize their Oscar - nominated roles in other movies , like sequels or spinoffs , down the line , but it ’s rarified that this return performance also gain a nominating address . To this daylight , only six actors in Oscars history have have nominations for both of their own portrayals of the same characterin different movies . Of these six actors , only one is an actress , and only two have gain either of their nominations . Most of the second nominating address were for sequels of the first films , but there are a few exceptions .
The Oscars 2024 subspecies is almost at its oddment , with Oppenheimer hop to dominate at the 96th Academy Awards . Can any of the other moving-picture show stop it ?
6Bing Crosby as Father Charles “Chuck” O’Malley
Going My Way (1944) & The Bells of St. Mary’s (1945)
In 1944 , Bing Crosby playedaRoman Catholic priest by the name of Father Charles " Chuck " O’Malleyin Leo McCarey’sGoing My agency . His performance realise him the first Oscar nominating speech and winnings of his decades - farsighted life history . Crosby did n’t waste any time reprising the role in the subsequence , The Bells of St. Mary’s , which premiered the year after the first motion-picture show . This return performance earned him another Best Actor nominating address , the second of his vocation .
Crosby ’s back - to - back nominations in 1945 and 1946 for his public presentation as Father Chuck O’Malley made himthe first actor to be nominated doubly for playing the same character in dissimilar movie . He is also one of only two actors on this list to win either of his nominating address for portray the same character . Crosby would go on to receive just one more Oscar nominationin 1955 before his decease many years later , in 1977 .
5Peter O’Toole as King Henry II
Becket (1964) & The Lion in Winter (1968)
Peter O’Toole became the next worker after Crosby to welcome a second nominating speech for a role he ’d played before . In 1964 , O’Toole receive an Oscar nomination for Best Actor forhis execution as King Henry II of EnglandinBecket , based on Jean Anouilh ’s manoeuvre by the same name . Four year later , O’Toole was put up again for playing the same historical swayer inThe Lion in Winter , establish on the play of the same name by the film ’s screenwriter , James Goldman .
While both picture have O’Toole as Henry II , The Lion in Winteris not turn over an official sequel toBecket . Regardless , O’Toole still played the same real - living person in both films and received Best Actor nominations for both . He may have lost both laurels , but he became a part of Oscars chronicle nonetheless .
4Al Pacino as Michael Corleone
The Godfather (1972) & The Godfather Part II (1974)
One of the most nominative male actors in Oscars story , Al Pacino has a sum of nine Oscar nominations . He ’s been nominated for five Best Actor awards ( include one winnings ) and is tie for the eminent number of Best Supporting Actor nominations with four nominations . Before he rack up these telling numbers , though , Pacino ’s first - ever Oscar nominating speech in 1973 was for his iconic role in Francis Ford Coppola’sThe Godfatherin the Best Supporting Actor category .
Pacino was nominated again two years afterwards for his return as Michael Corleone inThe Godfather Part II , this time for Best Actor . With these two nomination for playing this same eccentric inThe Godfathertrilogy , Al Pacino joined Crosby and O’Toole as one of the few actors nominate for playing a character reference more than once . Many year later , Pacino returned to the function in the trilogy ’s last installment , The Godfather Part III , in 1990 , but did not take in a nominating speech this time .
3Paul Newman as “Fast Eddie” Felson
The Hustler (1961) & The Color of Money (1986)
Newman received his first nominating speech for play puddle hooker " Fast Eddie " Felson before O’Toole ’s or Pacino ’s nominations , buthe had to wait 25 years for the second nominating address before he could join the nightclub . He ended up losing his nomination for Best Actor for his carrying into action as Eddie Felson inThe Hustlerin 1962 , but the long postponement turn up to be deserving it . In 1987 , Newman win for reprise the role in Martin Scorsese’sThe Color of Money , the continuation toThe Hustler .
With this winnings , Newman joined Crosby as the only two actors to win an Oscar for a character they flirt double . WhileThe Color of Moneywas his only competitive Oscar winnings , like Pacino , Newman remains one of the top nominated manful actor in Oscars history . Before his death in 2008 , Newman earned a total of nine Oscar nominations , all for Best Actor .
Alongside his Oscar wins , Newman also received two Honorary Awards .
2Cate Blanchett as Queen Elizabeth I
Elizabeth (1998) & Elizabeth: The Golden Age (2007)
One actress who is no unknown toOscars phonograph recording is Cate Blanchett . She has been propose for eight Oscars in total and is the only actor on this tilt with two private-enterprise Oscar win . Blanchett also befall to bethe only actress among these six actors with multiple same - lineament nomination .
In 1999,Blanchett received her first - ever Oscar nomination for playing Queen Elizabeth IinElizabeth(1998).She reprised the function in the sequel , Elizabeth : The Golden Age(2007 ) , and received another nomination for Best Actress for her second portrayal of the historic figure . This second nominating speech made Blanchett the first and only actress to be nominated twice for playing the same character reference . To this twenty-four hour period , no other actress has join Blanchett in achieving this feat .
1Sylvester Stallone as Rocky Balboa
Rocky (1976) & Creed (2015)
The most recent actor to receive a second nomination for the same theatrical role is Sylvester Stallone . Unlike the other actors on this inclination , who all boast multiple nominations and some win for other motion picture roles throughout their careers , Stallone has only ever received performing nominations for play the iconic boxer , Rock Balboa , a role he created . His first nomination was for Best Actor in 1977 for his first of many portrayals of the nominal character in the firstRockymovie .
Stallone would go on to star in five more installments of theRockyfranchise , but he did n’t receive another nominating speech for the role until nearly 40 years later , give himthe largest crack between Oscar nomination for play the same fibre . In 2016 , Stallone was propose for Best patronize Actor for recapitulate his purpose as Rocky Balboa in theRockyspin - off , Creed . Stallone keep on to play Rocky in the sequelCreed II , but was not put up for any moreOscars .
