Rebel Moon
Summary
Reviews for Zack Snyder ’s approaching sci - fi epicRebel lunation : Part One - A Child of Fireare out , and critic have been harsh on the director ’s modish offering . The picture show promises to guide interview through the first part of a place fantasy saga reminiscent ofStar Warsand the works of Akira Kurosawa , following a adult female named Kora as she scours the extragalactic nebula for warriors to help the plight of her humble farming moonlight , Veldt , against the tyrannical Motherworld empire . unluckily , Rebel Moonhas failed to sway the legal age of critical viewers , paintingeverything we know aboutRebel Moonin a new light .
At the time of writing , Rebel Moon : Part One - A Child of Firesits at an abysmal 26 % approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes . This is dangerously snug to thelowest - denounce Zack Snyder filmon the internet site , Sucker Punch , which maintain a petty 22 % paygrade . The moving picture has been have words by reviewers as being derivative , creatively belly-up and narratively uninteresting , an ominous showtime to the film ’s supposed status as a universe - establishing first installment . It seems as thoughRebel Moonis form up to be another contentious entry in Snyder ’s already divisive filmography .
Rebel Moon will be available to stream on Netflix on December 21st , 2023
8Rebel Moon Feels Like A Star Wars Knockoff
The film toes the line between inspiration and copy
A throughline literary criticism consistently leveled atRebel Moonfrom many reviewers is the film ’s want of originality . While Snyder did toy with the idea ofsetting Rebel Moon in the Star Wars universe , at it seems as though Snyder was n’t able to shake off the franchise ’s suffocating influence as a purportedly original tale , with TheWrap ’s William Bibbiani calling it aStar Warsknockoff that struggle to obtain its own identity ( viaTheWrap ) . take that the originalStar Warsmovie borrow heavily from the works of Akira Kurosawa , Snyder ’s ideas forRebel Moonaren’t entirely new .
7The Movie’s Characters Are Style Over Substance
Rebel Moon’s inhabitants don’t seem to have much depth
Characterization has been something Zack Snyder has struggled with before , with the flash and style of his dramatically - shot motion-picture show often doing the lowering lifting for the story . Reviewers have bashedRebel Moonfor continuing this trend , with Simon Abrams remarking " As common , Snyder does n’t seem to care about these characters so much as he wish their style - templet lineament , like their cleavage , their haircuts , and their firmly - distressed accents . " ( viaRoger Ebert.com ) . It remains to be seen whether these characters will be capable of carry the planned franchise any further .
6Rebel Moon Is Mostly Just Setup
The film’s lengthy full title is indicative of its inability to stand alone
Rebel Moon : Part One - A youngster of Fireboldly aim to launch an ongoing dealership , as proclaimed by its ambitious title . EvenSnyder acknowledge the first film is mostly setup , and critic appear to have admonish his effort in setting up a grander saga without crafting a movie that stands on its own . The Guardian ’s Charles Bamseco suspect as much in his revue , declaring " this 134 - minute film really only covers the have - the - gang together phase that most movies in the genre knock out within the first half hour " ( viaThe Guardian ) .
5Zack Snyder Mishandles Serious Topics
Rebel Moon isn’t nearly as PG as Star Wars
As a director , Zack Snyder has never shy away from less piquant stories that delve into some touchy subject topic , with flick likeSucker Punchusing intimate violence as motivation . Some critics have scolded his clumsy handling of such delicate subject , doing so again inRebel Moonto sour effect . Reviewer Clarisse Loughrey to boot analyze some troubling portrayal of LGBTQ+ communities inRebel Moon(viaIndependent ) , despite the film ’s inclusion of a notable non - binary booster , played by non - binary actor E Duffy .
4Rebel Moon Has Some Solid Performances
For all the criticism the movie has received, the cast hold up their end
Not every aspect ofRebel Moonhas been dragged through the mud by critic , as harsh as Rotten Tomatoes ' verdict may seem . Many reviewers have praised the moving picture ’s performances in spite of the film ’s many other shortcomings , particularly that ofAnthony Hopkins ' Jimmy . Indie Wire ’s David Ehrlich elaborates on this , belabor the full stop that the cast is the film ’s single saving grace and that Jena Malone ’s fictional character should be a " first - voting draftee to the Hall of Fame of Thankless Movie Performances " ( viaIndie Wire ) .
3Rebel Moon Feels Like More Of A Proof-Of-Concept Than A Story
Reviewers have frequently described the film’s lack of development
As the springboard for a marque new , whole original science fabrication universe , Rebel Moon : Part One - A Child of Firehas a lot of pressing to generate stake and establish a compelling story . Yet decisive reception hint that in the first photographic film ’s hurry to set upRebel Moon ’s universe , the human race - building has eclipsed the tale itself in importance . Los Angeles Times commentator Mark Olsendescribes as much , saying that “ ' Child of Fire ' already feels like too much tale throat - glade . "
2Rebel Moon’s Action Scenes Are Great
If there’s one thing Zack Snyder knows how to do well, it’s awesome fight choreography
If there ’s an disputation to be made for Zack Snyder as a director that strictly swear on elan over inwardness , there may exist fans of his piece of work who will put up withRebel Moon ’s defect as long as it has some capital action mechanism . Luckily , reviewers can agree that the choreography and fight scenes are an unmistakable strength of the burgeon series . Tom Beasly praises the flick ’s " howling stunt workplace " , teasing " A climactic face - off between Boutella and Skrein gets particularly nasty and inventive " ( viaThe Digital Fix ) .
1The Final Cut Of Rebel Moon Has Glaring Omissions
Snyder’s decision to build hype with multiple cuts may be working against him
After the success of Zack Snyder ’s cut ofJustice Leagueon HBO Max , it seems as though the director is leaning in to his reputation as the post - production succeeder physician . Netflix has promised an R - rated music director ’s cut ofRebel Moon , which may solve some of the pacing matter and shallow portrayal , begging the question as to why Snyder is bothering with disjoined edits count his originative control compared to Warner Bros. covetous treatment of theJustice Leaguefranchise . AsRebel Mooncritic Sheraz Farooqi attest , " at last , the decision to publish two versions of this film[ … ]feels like a trip " ( viaCinemadebate.com ) .
Sofia Boutella in Rebel Moon - Part One: A Child of Fire
Sofia Boutella in Rebel Moon - Part One: A Child of Fire
