Related
Summary
TheHarry Potterbooks revealed that James Potter economize Severus Snape ’s lifetime when they were at school together , and the movies missed the wry connection this event had with Snape ’s deathHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows . Harry first learned that his Father-God had saved his least favorite instructor during his first year at Hogwarts when Professor Dumbledore used the story to explain why Snape hated James ' boy so much . harmonize to the headmaster , Snape require to refund this life debt so he could go back to hating James in public security . However , later , theHarry Potterbooks explain that this was n’t entirely exact .
As is revealedinHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows , Snape protected Harry , despite his hate for him , because he make out Lily Potter . regrettably , Snape ’s descent into Dark conjuring trick resulted in Lily ’s dying since he had recite Lord Voldemort about the prophecy that take for Harry the baddie ’s most significant enemy . Dumbledore had say Harry about James preserve Snape ’s life because the schoolmaster call he would never let out the unfeigned rationality Snape protected Harry . Still , this is n’t to say that James ' actions at Hogwarts were n’t significant — in fact , they forecast Snape ’s own death .
The Deathly Hallows version of Snape ’s death had some problems , but the variety to the Harry Potter character ’s final job was for the best .
James Saved Snape’s Life In The Shrieking Shack - The Same Place Snape Would Later Be Killed
Though Harry heard about James saving Snape inHarry Potter and the Philosopher ’s Stone , it would n’t be untilHarry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkabanthat he learned the details . As it release out , young Severus was only in peril in the first berth because Sirius Black had told him about the secret passageway lead from the base of the Whomping Willow to the Shrieking Shack . Snape was eager to chance upon what James and his friends had been doing there , but what he did n’t realize was that there was a lycanthrope waiting for him on the other side . If James had n’t put a halt to Sirius ' trick , Snape would have been killed in the Shrieking Shack .
Ironically , this was the precise placement where Severus Snape would die decades later . InHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows , the Shrieking Shack was where Snape and Voldemort met to discuss the Elder Wand ’s loyalty . blot out within the secret passageway , Harry find the whole matter — Voldemort wrong determined that Snape was the true master of the Elder Wandand murdered the man to ensure he ca n’t be challenged . finally , there ’s a certain verse to the fact that these two significant moments in Snape ’s life would happen in on the dot the same locating .
Snape Owed James A Life Debt In Harry Potter, But His Death Resolved It
James saving Snape was far more complicated than Dumbledore made it sound inHarry Potter and the Philosopher ’s Stone . Though the headmaster made it seem as if Snape had a resentful appreciation for James ' interference , the character himself tell otherwise . He told Harry that James did n’t save his living out of the goodness of his heart . Rather , the leader of the Marauders did n’t want to get in trouble or break the fun of their little secret below the Whomping Willow . Ultimately , both version of this situation seem part accurate . James may have had selfish cause for saving Snape , but it does n’t change the fact that the Slytherin boy would have died otherwise .
Snape had been save by James , but his own actions make his savior ’s death years later .
TheHarry Potterbooks set up that when a superstar lay aside the life of another , they are owed a magical life debt . Dumbledore call off this " magic at its deepest , its most impenetrable , " and therefore , entirely inescapable . This was seen inHarry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkabanwhen Harry spared Peter Pettigrew ’s life ( which , again , pass off within the Shrieking Shack — another poetic connection).When Pettigrew later set about to kill Harry , destiny ensured he got his punishment . likewise , Snape had been save by James , but his own activeness caused his savior ’s dying long time later . Ultimately , fate allowed Snape to endure long enough to protect Lily ’s son , but he twist up dead in the Shrieking Shack however .
The Harry Potter Movies Changed The Location Of Snape’s Death (& Ruined This Ironic Twist)
As scrumptiously tragical as this ironic twirl is , theHarry Pottermovies left it out whole . Dumbledore made no mention of James save Snape in thePhilosopher ’s Stonemovie , and the event itself was never name inPrisoner of Azkaban . Even the sprightliness debt Pettigrew owe Harry , as well as the consequences , were left out . Then , as the final nail in the coffin , Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallowsmoved the location of Snape ’s deathfrom the Shrieking Shack to the boathouse . So , any reference to Snape owe James a life debt was pass over off from the motion picture .
Of course , this had no major impingement on the overall plot ofHarry Potter . Snape ’s death was still significant in theDeathly Hallowsmovie , disregardless of the location . Still , these insidious layers of connective tissue within the wizarding world are exactly what cause Harry ’s story so appealing . Destiny was sitting behind every recess , allowing Lily ’s sacrifice to come across through countless life , ensuring Harry ended up with the Deathly Hallows , seeing that Voldemort brought about his own downfall , and , of path , learn Severus Snape the power of a life story salve .
