Fuller House
Summary
Despite legitimate originative reasons behind the decision , theFull HouserebootFuller Housewould have been better off recast Michelle Tanner instead of her fictitious character not appear in the show at all . Full Housewas a feel - sound family sitcom from the 80s and 90s that follow widow Danny Tanner , who is left raising his three daughters after his married woman ’s death , with the help of the lady friend ' live - in uncles . A reboot of the dear sitcom calledFuller Housewas released on Netflix in 2016 , now revolve about on the two eldest Tanner daughters , DJ and Stephanie . well-nigh every master character reference from the original series returned forFuller Houseto some extent , except for one .
The only original master character fromFull Housewho does n’t make an coming into court inFuller Houseis Michelle , the new Tanner girl . Michelle was played bytwins Mary - Kate and Ashley Olsen onFull House , who made their acting debut on the show at just six months honest-to-goodness . The Gemini the Twins alternated work Michelle for the duration of the show until it wrapped with its 8th time of year in 1995 . However , when the idea of a reboot came up , neither of the Olsen Gemini was interested in reprise their role as Michelle inFuller House . This go forth producer with a hard dilemma regarding Michelle ’s case . However , while leaving Michelle out of the reboot altogether sure as shooting figure out a potential continuity issue , it was ultimately not the best decision for the serial publication .
Fuller House may have staged a beautiful send - off for the Tanner extended family , but it leaves several questions that may never ber answered .
Fuller House Should Have Recast Michelle (& Why The Sequel Series Didn’t)
They already had an ideal replacement
Even before production began on the reboot , manufacturer should have been prepared for the Michelle offspring . While it was said thatFuller Housestar and producerJohn Stamos was to blame for the Olsen Gemini ' absence inFuller Housedue to his failure to reach out to them personally , the twins had already on the side retired from roleplay by the timeFuller Housewas in the workings . The fact that they ’d barely acted since they turned 18 in 2004 , focusing instead on building their fashion empire , is more likely the reasonableness for their lack of interest in returning .
Since the Twin Falls were n’t on board , the producer ofFuller Houseconsidered recasting Michelle with Elizabeth Olsen , the twins ' untested sister who had become a successful workings actress by then . Elizabeth would have been the perfect replacement for Michelle : not only does she hold a familial resemblance to the original actresses , but Olsen ’s later study inWandavisionproves she would have nailed a kinsperson sitcom role likeFuller House . Unfortunately , the producer never seriously pursue this possibility , with the series’creator Jeff Franklin claiming that it " was just an idea " and that they " were never going to recast the role . "
However , theFuller Houseproducers should have ultimately reconsidered their position , since the character ’s absence seizure is a major game gob in the serial . Even if Elizabeth Olsen did n’t sign on , the reboot still would have been good off recast Michelle with another actress who take over at least some resemblance to the twins . The character did n’t have to be a part of the main cast again , but she could have made at least an appearance or two over the path ofFuller House ’s five seasons for leave audiences with some law of closure and a right account for her absence seizure .
After five seasons of Fuller House , the Tanner family once again wish bye . Here ’s everything that happened in the Full House twisting - off ’s stopping point .
Michelle’s Age In Full House Made Her One Of The Easiest Characters To Recast
Michelle was still a child when Full House ended in 1995
Recasting Michelle would have been a batch easier than most of the other case onFull House , considering how young she still was on the show . Michelle was the child of the Tanner family , and besides her cousin-german , Alex and Nicky , she was the youngest overall on the show . WhenFull Houseended in 1995 , Michelle was only eight years sure-enough .
The determination to cut the reference altogether is baffling .
Regardless of who played her , Michelle would have depend very different in the reboot 21 age later , because the character would n’t be a child anymore . While most viewing audience probably know what the Olsen twins bet like as adults , grown - up Michelle did n’t have to look precisely like they do now for a recast to work . As long as the actress frame to play Michelle as an grownup inFuller Househad exchangeable features to the Olsen twins when they were young , the recast would have been convert enough that viewing audience were able-bodied to suspend their sentience of mental rejection , avoiding any likely continuity egress . This makes the decision to disregard the character altogether even more baffling .
Fuller House hinted that Michelle is gone , and a different theory claims that the youngest Tanner tyke actually died in the Full House finale .
Leaving The Youngest Tanner Out Of Fuller House Made Her Absence Too Noticeable
Michelle should’ve appeared on Fuller House at least a few times
alternatively of recasting the role , Michelle was simply pen out ofFuller Houseentirely . Her absence seizure in the pilot program is recognise by revealing that Michelle is now working as a fashion interior designer in New York , a not - so - subtle consultation to the Olsens ' alternate life history route that prevented them from returning to the show . The characters stay to make sparingreferences to Michelle and the Olsen twins onFuller House , often in the physical body of meta - gag thatexplain Michelle ’s absence from major holidays and life effect while playfully tease the twins about their own aeonian absence from the show .
WhileFuller Housemay attempt to make excuses for Michelle ’s absence , just because she subsist in New York now does n’t mean she would never return to San Francisco to visit her sept . It would have been a mickle less jarring , given the tight - entwine family kinetics demonstrate throughout the series , if the part was simply remould . Michelle ’s story inFuller Housecould still have remained the same , but some reference of the character ’s importance to the widerFull Housenarrative would have been much more comforting . at long last , Michelle ’s entire absence fromFuller Housewas more obtrusive and bizarre than if the show had just recast her and played it off like she was the same person .
Cast
