Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone
Summary
It has been 26 years since J. K. Rowling ’s debut novelHarry Potter and the Sorcerer ’s Stonewas released , followed by a moving-picture show adaptation in 2001 , but consultation still have questions about the Wizarding World . “How does thaumaturgy work?“and"Why is anyone poor?“are mutual queries . In late years , theHarry Potterseries ' constitutional problem have become more and more apparent .
10The Wizarding World’s Vague Magic System
Why do certain Latin terms produce magic?
Of the thing thatdo not make sense about charming inHarry Potteris how spells are created and where magic come from . The incantation of spell are Romance words , but the only reason for this is so Harry and the other characters have something interesting to say while they are perform magic . Additionally , some wizards can perform spells without saying the words , while others do n’t need wands at all . One classroom scene explaining how magic works in season 1 , which would co-occur withSorcerer ’s Stonein theHarry Pottertimeline , would make the wizard system much strong .
9One-Note Portrayal Of Slytherin
Slytherin only has one character archetype.
Sorcerer ’s Stoneimmediately characterise everyone in Slytherin as defective . Harry urgently ask the Sorting Hat not to set him in Slytherin . Most of the characters associate with Slytherin are bullies like Draco Malfoy , if not straight-out villains like Voldemort . SinceSorcerer ’s Stonewas published , theHarry Potterfandom has grown to admit numerous proud Slytherins . character who areexceptions to the Slytherin stereotypeare play up , including Regulus Black , Horace Slughorn , and Andromeda Tonks . TheHarry PotterTV show has the opportunity to develop a more nuanced vision of this Hogwarts house .
Of all the Hogwarts houses in Harry Potter , Slytherins have the worst report . Do they merit it ? lease ’s examine Slytherin trait , serious and risky .
8The Dursleys' Abuse Is Mostly Overlooked
Child abuse is a secondary plot point in Harry Potter.
Harry ’s aunt and uncle make Harry sleep under the steps and imprison and lust him . YetSorcerer ’s Stoneframes Harry ’s life with the Dursleys as the pitiable , mundane world Harry escapeswhen Hagrid acquaint him to the Wizarding World . The movie and book of account color over the fact that this is not what Harry ’s animation should have been before Hogwarts . to boot , the Dursleysbecome a secondary problem compared to the menace of Voldemort . While Dumbledore ’s reasons for leave behind Harry with the Dursleys for twelvemonth are excuse later in the series , the show could still take this plot stage more seriously .
7Stereotypes Surrounding The Goblins
The Harry Potter Goblin controversy has been widely discussed.
Many people have now point out that the goblins who are the Wizarding World ’s banker are characterized by many antisemitic stereotypes . Several major issue and news show outlets , includingForbes , have publish detailed article on this result . For the goblins to work in theHarry Potterreboot , they would need to be completely reconceptualized . The showrunners should also expand the presence of goblins in the Wizarding World beyond Gringotts , since depicting all goblins as relegated to one profession is part of the way they are stereotyped .
6The Wizarding World’s Underdeveloped Economy
Why are the Weasleys poor?
Another payoff withHarry Potter’smagic system is that its limitation are not clear . Fans have pointed out thatit does not make signified for the Weasley mob to be poor when magic should eliminate many of their fiscal problems . Theoretically , there are things in the Wizarding Worldthe Weasleys require moneyto grease one’s palms that they can not create out of tenuous airwave . But this is never fully explained : InSorcerer ’s Stone , the Weasleys are only introduced as the sort family mocked by the moneyed Malfoys . Additionally , while Muggle families exchange money for Wizarding currentness is referenced in the books , it is not readable how Muggle - Borns acquire school provision in the movies .
The Harry Potter TV remake has the potential of being smashing , but there are various component work against it , including the franchise ’s popularity .
5The Story Revolves Around Gryffindor
The Harry Potter fandom includes members of all the Hogwarts houses.
Like with Slytherin , Hufflepuffs and Ravenclaws ( and Gryffindors ) proudly hold their house on social media forums . However , Sorcerer ’s Stonecenters on Gryffindor case , with a few antagonistic characters from Slytherin . Some side characters belonging toHufflepuff and Ravenclaware introduced in the late books and movies , but the only non - Gryffindor graphic symbol who is arguably a part of the principal cast is Luna Lovegood . This excludes some grownup fictional character whose house were confirmed outside the books and flick . TheHarry PotterTV show could tell a much more complex narrative if the season coincide withSorcerer ’s Stoneintroduces and develops some fiber from the other houses .
4Gendered Social Structure Of Witches And Wizards
The Wizarding World is strictly binary.
Sorcerer ’s Stoneintroducesa gendered guild where the men are mavin and the woman are beldame , with no sex - nonconforming characters appear . “Wizards"and"witches"are only label and all the character have the same abilities . In contrast , other witching systems categorise all the characters the same way . For illustration , inThe Owl House , they are all enchantress ( one wizard does come out in time of year 1 , episode 2 ) , while inWizards of Waverly Place , they are all thaumaturgist ( witches are now and again referenced ) . grant to Prema Arasu ( viauwa.edu.eu ) , the Wizarding World"is deeply structured around a patriarchal gender binary,“which is something else the show could alter .
3Lack Of Diversity In The Wizarding World
Harry Potter has been widely criticized for its primarily straight, white cast.
Harry Potter’sfew type who are hoi polloi of color are all pass on to side part . The only Hogwarts scholar of color to appear inSorcerer ’s Stoneis Dean Thomas , with some abbreviated citation made to Parvati and Padma Patil . According to entertainment insider Jeff Sneider ( viaCBR ) , HBO is make a"concerted effort"to cast"more people of color"in the reboot .
However , it is not cleared how HBO will handleHarry Potter’slack of LGBTQ+ fictitious character . Dumbledore ’s human relationship with Grindelwaldis never explicitly addressed in the original series but was confirmed after its decision . YetRowling ’s changes to theHarry Pottercanonhave progressively get at fans . Retconning the series to rationalize a lack of diversity does not solve the trouble – the show just need to have a more diverse cast .
There are many great Harry Potter fanfics out there , and there are a handful that are absolute must - reads for a variety of reasons !
2Confusing Dynamic Between Wizards And Muggles
There are supposedly strict laws about revealing magic to Muggles.
TheSorcerer ’s Stonenovel explains that the Ministry is responsible for hide the universe of thaumaturge from the non - magical world . Families ofMuggle - bear wizards and witchesare an exclusion , although it is not exonerated if this apply to just their parents or their lengthy category . However , some hotshot and hag marry Muggles . Most star are apparently completely incognizant of non - magical technology like telephone , cars , and television . Overall , it is not obvious where and how the bloodline between the magical and non - magical worlds is draw .
1Hogwarts' Mistreatment & Endangerment Of Children
The Forbidden Forest is dangerous and Snape is awful.
Hogwarts permits many dangerous bodily function , including Quidditch . teacher also sentence 11 - year - olds to hold in the Forbidden Forest , inhabited by wolfman and piece - eat spider . Meanwhile , professor can mistreat the students as much as they like . Snape browbeat his students throughoutSorcerer ’s Stone , particularly Harry and Neville , and the sequels show other teachers abusing their business leader . Hogwarts ' administration should be getting droves of letters from angry parents every calendar week . The show has the opportunity to change the dynamics at Hogwarts and other elusive plot point introduce inHarry Potter and the Sorcerer ’s Stone , or at least provide stronger justification for them .
origin : Forbes , uwa.edu.eu , CBR
