Related
Summary
There have been many bestselling books that have been adapt into feature picture , but there are some pic that fail to arrive at the success of their literary groundwork . In the Hollywood industry , it is see a risk to resolve to adapt certain record into picture show . The success of a book - to - film version always depends on its faithfulness to the source cloth and how it is seen by both critics and audience .
Books such asHarryPotter , LittleWomen , andLord of the Ringswere adapted into critically acclaimed movies that were financially successful and relatively close to their original story . Other film based on Scripture break to live up to their generator fabric and are often label a letdown by critics and audiences . Many bestselling novels did n’t work when they were made into filmsand many would concur that they worked better as a book .
10Eragon (2006)
Adapted from the 2002 novel by Christopher Paolini
The first book inThe Inheritance Cycleby Christopher Paolini , Eragontells the story of a immature farm boy who discovers a dragon ’s egg ; when the egg hatch into a firedrake , Eragon exact the dragon as his favorite . Their peaceable life are shatter when the vicious king find out about the egg and lay out out to take it for himself , leave behind Eragon and his new pet to fly their hometown with a storyteller who teaches him the path of Draco - horseback riding . The book was praised for its plot of land and characters , andit was name as one of the most popular nipper ’s books of the twenty-first 100 .
Eragonwas adapted into a movie in 2006 , starring Ed Speelers and Jeremy Irons . Despite being successful at the box office , it was negatively received by critics , with some describing the story as flat and the performances as exanimate . Plans to adjust the sequels into movies were finally canceled;however , in 2022 , it was announced that Disney would be remakingEragonas a video serial publication , which has hopes of being more successful than the film .
9The Lovely Bones (2009)
Adapted from the 2002 novel by Alice Sebold
Arguably one of the black books ever publish , The Lovely Bonesfocuses on a young girl , Susie Salmon , who , after being dishonor and dispatch , lookout over her family from heaven . From her place in the afterlife , Susie watch as her family struggle to come to terms with their loss and her killer seem for his next victim . The novel was an instant bestseller , receiving congratulations for merge tragedy and horror with a sense of promise after loss .
Peter Jackson , who worked on theLord of the Ringsfranchise , released a picture adjustment ofThe Lovely Bonesin 2009 . Saoirse Ronan and Stanley Tucci were highly praised for their performances , as Susie Salmon and George Harvey respectively . However , The Lovely Bonesreceived a mixed reply from interview , receiving criticism for overleap the darker aspects of the story that made the novel interesting ; it was only marginally successful at the box post and was broadly consider as lackluster compared to the original novel .
Stanley Tucci was put up for Best Supporting Actor at the 2010 Academy Awards for his performance inThe Lovely Bones .
8Dune (1984)
Adapted from the 1965 novel by Frank Herbert
Frank Herbert ’s 1965 novel , Dune , is often regard as one of the dandy scientific discipline fiction books ever written . Set in the future , in an interstellar society , 15 - year - old Paul Atreides , whose family accepts the stewardship of the planet Arrakis , the only major planet live to farm spice that enhances a person ’s mental power ; their acceptance solvent in contention and betrayal , forcing Paul to confront his true fate . Dunewas an instant succeeder , receive five continuation novel ; after Herbert died in 1986 , his son Brian later wrote an extra 12 account .
Duneis notorious for being difficult to adjust into a film ; the 1984 motion-picture show starring Kyle MacLachlan was released after lallygag in development hell for geezerhood . The movie fail with critic and audiences , lose $ 12 million at the box authority and being called empty and moth-eaten compare to the novel ; the director , David Lynch , has since distanced himself from the movie . The 2021 remaking , star Timotheé Chalamet as Paul Atreides , received far stronger reviews than the 1984 film .
Denis Villeneuve and David Lynch are get it on for their styles of directing , so there are big differences between the modern and 1984 version of Dune .
7The Great Gatsby (2013)
Adapted from the 1925 novel by F. Scott Fitzgerald
The smashing Gatsbywritten by F. Scott Fitzgerald , is one of the most pop books ever written and studied . coif in the Jazz Age , it looks at the story of the millionaire Jay Gatsby , who is determined to reunify with his old fan Daisy ; the story is recite by his neighbor Nick Carraway , who gets caught up in their romance .
There have been many moving-picture show adaptations ofThe Great Gatsbywith the 2013 film star Leonardo DiCaprio as the mysterious millionaire . It polarise critics , with some praise the costumes and set up designs for bide dead on target to the original storey , with others criticizing the movie for over - lard the story . While the movie was visually sensational , many agree that it ’s one of the weakest adaptation of Fitzgerald ’s acclaim novel .
6Beautiful Creatures (2013)
Adapted from the 2009 novel by Kami Garcia and Margaret Stohl
Set in a small township in Gatlin , South Carolina , Beautiful Creaturessees a teenage male child name Ethan who is desperate to escape his small - town life . Everything deepen when he meets the beautiful Lena , and after learn her clandestine , vow to do everything he can to protect her . The first book in theCaster Chronicles , Beautiful Creatures , try out democratic and received three continuation , continuing Ethan and Lena ’s story .
Beautiful Creatureswas one of many young grownup phantasy novels made into movie in the 2010s . However , by the sentence it was released , in 2013 , the popularity of the YA genre had refuse rapidly . The moving picture failed to yarn-dye audience , with critic ring it camp , clichéd , and void of any magic . AfterBeautiful Creaturesfailed at the box office , the idea to continue filming theCaster Chronicleswas finally abandon .
5I Am Number Four (2011)
Adapted from the 2010 novel by Pittacius Lore
The first book in theLorien Legaciesseries , I Am Number Fourlooks at an ongoing fight between two foreign mintage , the Loric and the Magdalorians . The Lorics have almost been completely pass over out , with only 9 survivors escaping to Earth . After three are killed , the quaternary , going by the name John , must retrieve a way to escape being belt down , while also keeping his powers hidden from his new human friends .
I Am Number Fourwas release as a movie in 2011,starring Alex Pettyfer and Dianna Agron . Critics were not fans of the flick , call it a forgettable sci - fi thriller ; it also failed at the box office , gross less than $ 150 million . In an consultation for the 10th anniversary of the flick , Alex Pettyfer tell that while he loved makingI Am Number Four , the dingy fiscal results of the film get Universal to scratch the dealership altogether .
4The Scarlet Letter (1995)
Adapted from the 1850 novel by Nathaniel Hawthorne
The Scarlet Letter , written by Nathaniel Hawthorne , is arguably one of the great American Book ever written . It examines the scrutiny and ostracism that unmarried mother faced in the nineteenth century , through the eyes of Hester Prynne , who is punished by her community for having a child with a matrimonial gentleman . She is forced to weary a ruby-red letter of the alphabet on her hide and struggles to produce a new life for herself and her shaver .
Many movies were publish found onThe Scarlet Letter , with the 1995 movie starring Gary Oldman and Demi Moore . The motion picture was universally panned , with many believing it moved too far from the original novel . It win the Golden Raspberry Award for Worst Remake or Sequel andmany critics have cited it as one of the worst book - to - movie adaptations in history .
The Scarlet Letterreceived a total of 7 nomination at the 1995 Golden Raspberry Awards , including Worst Picture .
3The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones (2013)
Adapted from the 2007 novel by Cassandra Clare
Another young grownup novel , City of Bones , was the first inThe Mortal Instrumentsseries written by Cassandra Clare . It follows a teen , Clary Fray , who finds herself uncover the secrets of her yesteryear , as she finds herself drawn into the world of Shadowhunters . City of Bonesproved pop as a book and saw five further novels released in later years .
Starring Lily Collins and Jamie Campbell Bower , City of Boneswas released as a movie in 2013 . It received a piteous reception from critics , with some advert it as another boring illusion plastic film that would only gruntle unfeigned fans . The vital bankruptcy of the film and its mediocre box office draws , result in movie plans for the 2nd book , City of Ashes , being scrapped;a TV serial publication reboot , Shadowhunters , was give up in 2016 , which received a warmer response from viewing audience .
Shadowhunters first aired in 2016 , and it ran for three seasons on Freeform . Here ’s what the hurl has been up to since the series enfold up in 2019 .
2The Cat in the Hat (2003)
Adapted from the 1957 novel by Dr. Seuss
Dr. Seuss is often regarded as one of the cracking kid ’s writers in chronicle . One of his most pop write up wasThe Cat in the Hat , where a talking cat wear thin a cerise - and - white striped lid , causes chaos in the home of two siblings on a rainy afternoon . The leger attain insistent critical and commercial success andhas often been listed as one of the greatest tyke ’s books in story .
The Cat in the Hatwas free as a live - action film in 2003 , asterisk Mike Myers and Alec Baldwin;it try out a critical and commercial disaster , bomb at the box office and receiving heavy literary criticism for its humor and adult theme in a children ’s film . It experience 8 nominations at the 2004 Golden Raspberry Awards , win a particular honor for Worst apology for an Actual Movie . Plans to take the sequelThe Cat in the Hat Comes Backwere in the end cancel .
The decisive and commercial failure ofThe Cat in the Hat , resulted in Dr. Seuss ' widow woman , Audrey Geisel , prohibiting any further live - action adaptation of her hubby ’s work .
1Battlefield Earth (2000)
Adapted from the 1982 novel by L. Ron Hubbard
L. Ron Hubbard , the father of the Scientology religious belief , liberate this skill - fiction novel in 1982.Battlefield Earthis set in 3000 AD , where an foreign metal money ring Psychlos has invaded Earth ; after a thousand year , one human , Jonnie Tyler , decides that it ’s time to struggle back . The book in general divided critics , but it trade well and is reckon by many proofreader as a comme il faut sci - fi novel .
John Travolta campaigned for years to haveBattlefield Earthcreated into a moving-picture show ; however , the final issue , released in 2000 , was a universal disaster , receive vituperative reviews for its plot , overutilization of Dutch angles , and inadequate special effects . Its failure at the box office staff resulted in its production troupe , Franchise Pictures , filing for failure . The movie won every award it was propose for at the 2001 Golden Raspberry Awards , subsequently succeed a special award for Worst Picture of the Decade . Often see as one of the bad movies of all time , Battlefield Earthproved to be one of the biggest successful novels that completely fail as a movie .
